Finding the perfect winter hat is trickier than it seems. I went through plenty of disappointing beanies before finally discovering one I truly loved. Here’s my story, so you can skip the trial and error!
My first purchase was a bargain buy—one of those cute solid knitted beanie hats for kids I found online for around $5. At the time, I thought it was a steal. I couldn’t have been more mistaken.

It barely lasted a few weeks before starting to unravel. The knit was loose, and it didn’t even provide much warmth. The so-called fleece lining was thin and scratchy—definitely not what I’d call a warm knitted beanie with fleece for women. I should have checked the reviews more carefully. In the end, it wasn’t worth even five dollars.
Here’s what went wrong:
Verdict: Steer clear of ultra-cheap beanies. They’re just a waste of money.
Next, I moved up to a mid-range option, spending about $15 on a beanie that looked promising online. It was… alright. Definitely an improvement over the first, but still not ideal. The knit was tighter and the fleece a bit thicker, so it kept me warmer. Comfort, though, wasn’t quite there.
The main issue was the fit—it was too tight, giving me a headache after just a few hours of wear. The color also didn’t match the online photos. I noticed a review that simply said, “it’s okay,” which in hindsight was a red flag.
Here’s what I learned: